Samantha GreenMar 27th, 2008 - 05:04:01

Chikezie should not have been booted. Malubay, kristy, Jason Castro should have been in the bottom three with Malubay getting the boot. Once again Idol is turing in to a popularity contest with the real talent getting kicked off and the weak staying around.Just think back to Taylor Hicks Rubin Studderd please let not make the same mistakes over and over again..Seven seasons and only three good idols and one of them was in thrid place.

Report this comment

amberMar 27th, 2008 - 05:35:03

u can shut it he sucked had like 2 good week jason is a good signer he jus needs to prove it and soo does the ram.....

Report this comment

hahahahMar 27th, 2008 - 06:46:06

Oh what the hell! America got it wrong? Chikizee is going to leave sooner than later anyway and glad that he left sooner! He's not impressive! And cut Ramiele some slack and admit your wrong predictions. She made it through and vote for her because of her performance!

David Archuelta is a little weird and I can find myself liking him from the beginning. I'll be greatly dissappointed if he makes it to the TOP 2!!

Report this comment

donMar 27th, 2008 - 15:46:07

America got it right. He was the one to go and I hope David C. goes next. He is so cocky and totally ugly. He really does look like an alien.

Report this comment

I agree......Mar 27th, 2008 - 19:18:13

with Simon on most of his advice. It's too bad that a lot of the contestants get so uptight at him. He is the expert and knows what sells, so if they want to get anywhere, they better listen and learn. After all, it's called 'American Idol', and they are out to find the singer who appeals to the general buying public. Sure, a lot of them have good voices, but they aren't going to appeal to the pop culture out there. They need to sing songs that have audience appeal, not what they like to sing. I always hate it when a singer I like decides to start singing only the songs that appeal to them and not what the public likes.
That isn't what sells for the most part. If they are really good, they are going to get noticed even if they get voted off, which has been proven over and over. 'American Idol' is a good vessel for that.

Report this comment